About Mugs Award Winners How to Apply

2002 Mugs Stump Award Winners:
Maddaloni/Kelly—Meru Shark's Fin

Matt Maddaloni & Damien Kelly

It took a week to arrive in Tapovan base camp at 4200 meters. Blizzarding with 5 feet of snow where at this time of year there should be sun and grass. Locals say that the monsoon lasted a month longer than normal. All the mountains are sumerged in a heavy snow pack. Damien got really sick from the water and food. He didn't stop puking blood for just under 24 hours. The only thing that worked was injectable gravol before he was able to drink liquid. I got altitude sick and puked myself for one night, I was the only one not on Diamox. I stayed waiting in base camp really weak while John Millar, Guy Edwards and Conor Reynolds, our Canadian friends brought Damien back to health so we could descend. In the ongoing blizzard which lasted 9 days and collapsed our cook tent twice to the point it was unrepairable, Damien and I decended to Gangotri, two days away. Our Liason Officer, Baskar, came with us and we spent 5 days recovering. Upon return we got our strenght back and the snow had stopped leaving Tapovan buried in snow and the peaks in glorious sun. Many expeditions had left, believing even the west ridge of Shivling was unclimable this year. Damien and I moved a load up to advanced base camp at 5100 meters and quickly descended the same day leaving a stash of gear. The altitude really effected me so we slept lower at BC.

Upon return the snow pack had thawed enough for serious post holeing resulting in a tendon or ligament in my knee seizing. I couldn't walk without help for the last 300 feet to camp and I spent the next 5 days recovering in BC. Damien went back to ABC and aclimatized. He spent some time soloing up the west ridge of Shivling and made it to camp 1.

Days later I radioed Damien on his situation and made preparations to move the last of our gear to ABC. Damien had been watching Meru's ice face which was plastered with unconsolidated snow watching for it to avalanche for four days. He figured I should bring a smaller pack and test my knee before commiting all our gear to ABC. He had a hunch that Meru would be almost impossible for an alpine style ascent due to the waist deep vertical snow waiting to blast down and wipe us out. I arrived in ABC at 6 am and felt acclimatized and feeling that my knee had healed enough for an attempt on Meru.

At this point Damien had lost all hope for Meru due to a British teams report on the lower ice face being completly unconsolidated. It was now getting colder and there was no freeze / thaw cycle happening high on Meru and the snow hadn't avalanched off as of yet. Disapointed to the fact that we had suffered so much to reach this point and not have a chance at the mountain, we stayed in ABC that afternoon. We wanted to make sure we hadn't made a hasty decision and later that evening still feeling we had made the right choice we grabbed all our gear in a heavy load and decended to BC. At this point I was unsure about my weaking knee so Damien and I split up for 3 days. He became sick again but recovered quickly enough to try for another run at Shivling. An Austrian team had spent two weeks shoveling there way to camp 2 and were now fighting the overhanging serac pitch. An Isralie team had made it to camp 1 and fixed ropes on the upper ridge below camp 2. From BC at 4200 meters Damien in a 15 hour push made it to 5700 meters, just below camp 2 before the rigors of climbing solo and the severe altitude gain in such a short time convinced him to turn around. He did manage to sleep 2 hours at camp one in an Isralie tent before trying the upper ridge and then turning around. He says if he had brought a sleeping bag he might of attemted to survive the night and try the summit but as is he suffered mild frostbitten fingers and toes.

I grabbed what I needed for three days and using two approach poles the Isralies lent me I hiked 10 km up the Gangotri glacier for photo opportunities. I got to see Shivling and Meru from the back and Bhargarathi III and Kedar Dome upclose. I would of continued to the base of Swachand, another 15 km away, where the other three Canadians were climbing it's east face, but my knee was becoming severly painfull again. I figured I was exposed enough being 10 km away from any help so I packed up and slowly made my way back to BC. Damien and I decided Meru wasn't going to be climable this year so we decided to leave. Jules Cartwright's British climbing team also decided to give up on Meru, this being his second attempt, the last one was six years ago where he made the highest attempt to just below the final Sharksfin. We pooled our resources and made our way back to Delhi for some good food, beer and Indian night clubbing. On the way out my knee became worse and couldn't bend my knee for the last couple of kilometers.

We did manage to get some amazing photos and did some incredible bouldering even though there was still lots of snow at the end. I havn't seen any pics yet since I'm still in Delhi. Met some amazing climbers from around the world. Managed to solo a 500 foot spire/ridge on Shivlings north side out of Tapovan. Amazing day, used my approach shoes and no rope on amazing clean swept granite. Tried three different corner systems before I found a more confortable way to the top. Standing above Tapovan I could see all the expedition tents far below and the glistening rivers that wandered among them. ABC was far behind me up the Meru glacier and far in the distance were my three friends on Swachand. Their progress is still unknown to us due to our leaving before they returned.

Matt Maddaloni
Tel: 604.898.8321
PO Box 2393
Garibaldi Highlands BC V0N 1T0

Back to Award Winners

Sponsored by: